Foreign Insult: English Baroque Music by Expatriate Composers - La Ricordanza

Posted By: zamorna
Avengers - Age of Ultron Prelude - This Sceptre d Isle Infinite Comic 001 (2015)

Foreign Insult: English Baroque Music by Expatriate Composers - La Ricordanza
(G. F. Handel, F. Barsanti, G. Finger, J. C. Bach, N. Mattteis, C. F. Abel)

Classical, Baroque | 1 CD | EAC | FLAC, CUE, LOG | Scans | 339 MB | RS
Recorded: 5-7 Oct. 2004, Schloß Gifthorn, Germany | Released: 2006
Label: Dabringhaus und Grimm MDG 505 1381-2 | TT: 65:58

La Ricordanza (Brian Berryman - flute, Annette Berryman - oboe & recorder,
Christoph Heidemann, Katharina Huche-Kohn - violin, Bettina Ihrig - viola,
Dorothée Palm - cello, Barbara Hofmann - violone, Eckhart Kuper - harpsichord)

The title of this album is a little misleading. In England as in France, there was resistance to the charms of Italian opera in the early eighteenth century; the phrase "foreign insult" comes from a screed bewailing the "Italian squalling tribe" and combining anti-Catholicism with misogyny as it goes on to condemn the "Popery in wit" and "unadorn'd Efffeminacy" of imported operas and plays. But there was little if any resistance to the hugely successful instrumental music penned by foreign composers, Handel being the most famous, who followed the money to prosperous London. Other editorial errors are on view in the booklet; the deathdate of Francesco Barsanti, for example, is given as 1722 rather than 1772.

No matter. Accurately titled or not, this is a superb recording of English Baroque music. It captures the crackling commercial energy that united the music of the Germans and Italians at work in the English capital. Most interesting of all are the four short selections from A Collection of Old Scots Tunes by Barsanti. Preceding Moore's Irish songs and Beethoven's and Haydn's arrangements of Scots and Irish songs by nearly 100 years, these are very early examples of musical exoticism. (And "clout the cauldron" may be the most exotic sexual metaphor to appear on disc for quite some time.) Barsanti's arrangements for flute and continuo emphasize the unusual nature of the material with unusual passages for flute alone. The Ground After the Scotch Humor for recorder, violin, and continuo of Nicola Matteis, from 1685, also marks a fascinating and sharp engagement on the part of its composer with the rhythmically distinct profile of Scottish music. Other immigrant composers represented include Handel, Johann Christian Bach, Carl Friedrich Abel, and Gottfried Finger, who became Godfrey Finger in England and whose Sonata in C major for recorder, cello, and continuo, Op. 5/10, shows the market-driven quality of the English repertory in its unusual instrumental combination: Finger solves the problems created by using the murky cello as a solo instrument and setting it against the piercing recorder. Germany's La Ricordanza historical-instrument ensemble plays all this music with consummate skill, appropriate warmth, and real enthusiasm. The usually superb sonics of the MDG label are a little off here; the recording environment of Saxony's Gifhorn Castle is a bit too big and chilly for music that would have originated in the well-appointed apartments that still line London's streets today. But the sound never detracts from the listener's enjoyment of some largely obscure and altogether worthwhile music. (James Manheim, All Music Guide)
There were few Court appointments for musicians in the precarious financial climate of the late 17th century English Royal Court; not to mention the rather frequent regime changes. But London was one of the richest cities in Europe so there developed a lively musical culture catering to the aristocracy and the burgeoning middle classes. As a result, continental musicians frequently came to England to try and make their fortunes and sometimes stayed. The more adventurous or restless composer could eschew the unexciting safety of a continental court appointment for the opportunity of being a freelance musician in London.

Being some distance from the European centres of the musical avant-garde, Londoners were often keen to learn of new fashions and styles from musicians freshly arrived from the continent. The history of baroque music in England after Henry Purcell is very much the history of assimilation of foreign musicians and foreign styles.

This new disc provides a brief survey of chamber music written by foreign composers. The chamber music on this disc was published in London to provide music for the keen amateur market. This is not concert music, but music written for the consumption of talented amateur musicians in their own chambers.

La Ricordanza are an Early Music chamber ensemble founded originally by musicians from the Royal Conservatory in the Hague and the Hochschule for Music and Theatre in Hanover. Their programmes often contain unpublished and forgotten works. On this disc they consist of eight players (flute, oboe/recorder, two violins, viola, cello, violone, harpsichord) and the players come together in various combinations.

The earliest of the composers on the disc is Nicola Matteis, who arrived in London in 1670. Roger North provides most of the biographical information that we have; evidently Matteis was instrumental in revolutionising English violin playing. His book of ‘Ayres’ was extremely well received and went into a second edition two years after its original publication. His ‘Ground after the Scotch Humour’ is a charming example of his attempts to adjust his works to the British taste.

Godfrey Finger was a Moravian composer and gamba player. In 1686 he was a member of James II’s Catholic chapel but after 1688 he stayed on as a freelance impresario, composer and performer. He published numerous chamber works as well as music for the theatre. He left England in 1701 in high dudgeon as his setting of Congreve’s ‘The Judgement of Paris’ failed in the notorious competition; it is possible that the outcome was rigged. On this disc La Ricordanza play his Sonata Op. 5 No. 10 for the unusual combination of recorder, obbligato cello and continuo. It is from a set that Finger possibly used to finance his exit from England.

The best known foreign composer resident in England is of course Handel. La Ricordanza choose to play two of his compositions for which we have no secure date, but whose manuscripts may have come to England with Handel on his first arrival. We lack an autograph manuscript for the Oboe Concerto in G minor but it survives from a 1740 collection printed by John Walsh in London. Handel seems to have revised the work for publication, something that he did not always do. La Ricordanza successfully perform the work in a chamber version with single strings that makes charmingly convincing chamber music. It brings to mind a picture of Handel’s supporters recreating music from his concerts in their own homes by playing such pieces. The other pieces, the trio sonata in F major for violin, oboe and basso continuo is of more dubious parentage. An oboist in the Haymarket Theatre orchestra in 1745/25 owned a set of trio sonatas that included this piece. On being shown it, Handel commented that it was a youthful work and that he ‘wrote like the devil back then, and mostly for the oboe, my favourite instrument’. So it may be one of the rare surviving works from Handel’s Halle period, or it may not. Still it is an attractive and effective piece and deserves to be heard, especially in a performance as ingratiating as this.

Francesco Barsanti was a colleague of Geminiani; they both travelled to England in 1714 to seek their fortune with the Italian opera. Barsanti emigrated to Edinburgh, married a local girl and went native, integrating himself fully into Scots musical life. In 1742 he published his collection of thirty ‘Old Scots Tunes’. La Ricordanza have recorded four of them, ‘Lochaber’, ‘Where Helen Lies’, ‘Clout the Cauldron’ and ‘Corn Riggs are Bonny’. The arrangements are charming and effective; the selection starts with a wonderfully plangent flute solo before Barsanti goes on to add accompaniment. His versions never overwhelm the melodic charm of the songs.

Johann Christian Bach was enticed away from an uneventful career as organist at Milan Cathedral by the prospect of commercial success writing operas for the King’s Theatre in London. He moved to London in 1762, initially for a year but in fact he stayed until his death in 1782. His six quintets op. 11 were dedicated to the Elector Palatine, in Mannheim, who was a famous connoisseur of music. They were performed by the Queen’s Band under Bach’s direction. The Quintet has an easy grace and the obbligato keyboard part is typical of Bach’s writing.

Carl Friedrich Abel fled Germany as a result of war. Abel was employed in the court orchestra in Dresden at the time it was invaded by Frederick the Great’s troops. Once in London, he joined the fashionable circles around Queen Charlotte - herself German speaking of course. Together with Johann Christian Bach he produced an annual concert series which ran for 26 years; each concert series being of ten to fifteen concerts. It is via these concert series that many foreign musicians were introduced to London. This Flute concerto in E minor may well have been played at one of these concerts.

La Ricordanza’s performances are enchanting; they make the best possible case for this music. There is a very real chamber feel about these performances, involving the give and take of friends or well known colleagues, something which helps us recapture the spirit of the original pieces. They play crisply and cleanly with a good sense of line and a nice feel for the articulation. More than that, you feel that they are enjoying themselves.

Even with the disc’s catchy title, this repertoire can seem a little forbidding. But don’t let that put you off. Buy the disc and be caught up in the spell of these performances. (Robert Hugill,, 2006)

Without doubt, this is music of exceptional quality and panache and 'La Ricordanza' get to the skin of these exquisite and delightful compositions with an insight that is astoundingly detailed. Since its founding in 1991, this ensemble has grown from strength to strength and 15 years on, it is regarded as one of the foremost groups in the interpretative field of baroque music. Presentation and sound are of the standards we have come to expect from this German label, who month after month keep enriching the catalogue with truly exceptional issues. Another first rate disc which should not be missed. (Gerald Fenech,, 2006)


Georg Frideric HANDEL (1685-1759)
01-04 Concerto HWV 287 in G minor (8:25)

Francesco BARSANTI (1690-1772)
05-08 A Collection of Old Scots Tunes – selection (published 1742) (9:13)

Gottfried FINGER (1660-1730)
09-13 Sonata Op.5 No.10 in C major (published 1701) (5:09)

Johann Christian BACH (1735-1782)
14-16 Quintet Op.11 No.6 (published 1774) (13:18)

Nicola MATTEIS (18th century)
17 Ground after the Scotch Humour (4:09)

Georg Frideric HANDEL
18-21 Trio Sonata HWV 383 in F major (10:14)

Carl Friedrich ABEL (1723-1787)
22-24 Concerto in E minor (14:53)

Exact Audio Copy V0.99 prebeta 5 from 4. May 2009

EAC extraction logfile from 27. December 2009, 16:19

La Ricordanza / Foreign Insult

Used drive : HL-DT-STDVDRAM GSA-T50N Adapter: 0 ID: 1

Read mode : Secure
Utilize accurate stream : Yes
Defeat audio cache : Yes
Make use of C2 pointers : No

Read offset correction : 667
Overread into Lead-In and Lead-Out : No
Fill up missing offset samples with silence : Yes
Delete leading and trailing silent blocks : No
Null samples used in CRC calculations : Yes
Used interface : Native Win32 interface for Win NT & 2000

Used output format : User Defined Encoder
Selected bitrate : 1024 kBit/s
Quality : High
Add ID3 tag : No
Command line compressor : C:\Program Files\Exact Audio Copy\FLAC\FLAC.EXE
Additional command line options : -6 -V -T "ARTIST=%a" -T "TITLE=%t" -T "ALBUM=%g" -T "DATE=%y" -T "TRACKNUMBER=%n" -T

"GENRE=%m" -T "COMMENT=%e" %s -o %d

TOC of the extracted CD

Track | Start | Length | Start sector | End sector
1 | 0:00.00 | 2:39.17 | 0 | 11941
2 | 2:39.17 | 1:40.12 | 11942 | 19453
3 | 4:19.29 | 2:18.72 | 19454 | 29875
4 | 6:38.26 | 1:51.44 | 29876 | 38244
5 | 8:29.70 | 4:19.30 | 38245 | 57699
6 | 12:49.25 | 2:31.63 | 57700 | 69087
7 | 15:21.13 | 0:59.26 | 69088 | 73538
8 | 16:20.39 | 1:28.11 | 73539 | 80149
9 | 17:48.50 | 1:24.41 | 80150 | 86490
10 | 19:13.16 | 1:45.36 | 86491 | 94401
11 | 20:58.52 | 0:28.64 | 94402 | 96565
12 | 21:27.41 | 0:37.44 | 96566 | 99384
13 | 22:05.10 | 0:58.61 | 99385 | 103795
14 | 23:03.71 | 6:56.26 | 103796 | 135021
15 | 30:00.22 | 3:34.00 | 135022 | 151071
16 | 33:34.22 | 2:52.56 | 151072 | 164027
17 | 36:27.03 | 4:15.64 | 164028 | 183216
18 | 40:42.67 | 2:33.15 | 183217 | 194706
19 | 43:16.07 | 1:46.62 | 194707 | 202718
20 | 45:02.69 | 2:27.40 | 202719 | 213783
21 | 47:30.34 | 3:33.01 | 213784 | 229759
22 | 51:03.35 | 5:33.50 | 229760 | 254784
23 | 56:37.10 | 4:53.67 | 254785 | 276826
24 | 61:31.02 | 4:25.32 | 276827 | 296733

Range status and errors

Selected range

Filename C:\La Ricordanza - Foreign Insult.wav

Peak level 94.6 %
Range quality 100.0 %
Test CRC 4A11E16A
Copy CRC 4A11E16A
Copy OK

No errors occurred

AccurateRip summary

Track 1 not present in database
Track 2 not present in database
Track 3 not present in database
Track 4 not present in database
Track 5 not present in database
Track 6 not present in database
Track 7 not present in database
Track 8 not present in database
Track 9 not present in database
Track 10 not present in database
Track 11 not present in database
Track 12 not present in database
Track 13 not present in database
Track 14 not present in database
Track 15 not present in database
Track 16 not present in database
Track 17 not present in database
Track 18 not present in database
Track 19 not present in database
Track 20 not present in database
Track 21 not present in database
Track 22 not present in database
Track 23 not present in database
Track 24 not present in database

None of the tracks are present in the AccurateRip database

End of status report

Rapidshare Links